$100 minimum order·Free shipping over $500

Craftsmanship

Yeast: The Ingredient Nobody Talks About

Grain gets a mash bill on the label and wood gets the credit for flavour. The organism that actually makes the alcohol is kept in a locked fridge and never mentioned.

Eleanor Hayes

Master Distiller, Bourbon & Oak

Nov 2, 20268 min read
Bourbon mash fermenting in an open fermenter, where yeast does the work that decides much of the flavour

A bourbon label will tell you the grain. A tour will spend twenty minutes on the barrel. Almost nobody will tell you about the yeast, and that is strange, because yeast is the only thing in the building that is alive and the only thing that actually makes alcohol.

It is also, at a lot of distilleries, the most closely guarded thing on site.

What Yeast Is Actually Doing

The cooker turns starch into sugar. Yeast turns that sugar into alcohol and carbon dioxide — but it does not stop there, and the rest is the interesting part. Alongside the ethanol it throws off a crowd of other compounds: esters, acids, aldehydes, higher alcohols. Collectively these are congeners, and they are where fruit, floral notes, banana, pear, green apple and a good deal of spice come from.

Wood cannot put fruit into whiskey. Oak gives vanilla, caramel, coconut, baking spice and colour. If you are getting ripe banana or stewed apple off a glass of bourbon, the yeast put it there during a few days in the fermenter, and the barrel spent years failing to cover it up.

  • Alcohol is the yeast's main product; the congeners are the flavour.
  • Fruit and floral notes trace to fermentation, not to the barrel.
  • Fermentation temperature changes the result — run hot and you get different esters than running cool.
  • Fermentation length matters too, with longer ferments generally building more character.
  • The same strain in two different houses will still behave differently, because everything around it differs.

Why Distilleries Guard Their Strain

A mash bill can be copied in an afternoon. Anyone can buy new charred oak. A yeast strain that a distillery has propagated continuously for decades cannot be bought, and it is the one component of a house style a competitor genuinely cannot replicate.

So the strains get treated like crown jewels. They are held in multiple locations in case of fire. There are long-told stories in Kentucky of distillers taking a jar of yeast home at the weekend so that a single disaster could not end a lineage, and whether or not every version of that story is literally true, the instinct behind it is real.

Sour Mash Is Not a Flavour

You will see "sour mash" on a great many labels and it is widely misread as a taste. It is not. It is a process control, and it exists to protect the yeast.

A portion of spent mash from a previous distillation — the backset — goes into the new cook. That drops the pH, which does two useful things: it discourages the bacteria that would otherwise compete with the yeast, and it gives each batch a consistent starting acidity. The result is that batch two hundred ferments like batch one.

It is the brewing equivalent of a sourdough starter, and like a sourdough starter its purpose is consistency rather than sourness. Almost every Kentucky bourbon is made this way, which is why the phrase on a label tells you considerably less than it appears to.

What You Can Taste, and What to Ask

Try this with two bourbons of similar age and proof from different houses. Set aside the oak notes — the vanilla, the caramel, the char — and concentrate on everything else. The fruit, the florals, the particular shape of the spice: that is the fermentation talking, and it is the most reliable signature of where a whiskey was made.

It is also why single barrel bottlings are worth paying attention to. With no blending to average things out, whatever the yeast did in that one fermenter is still sitting in the glass, which is part of why two bottles of the same label can differ so much.

If you are ever on a tour with someone who actually works there, ask how long they have run their strain and what they think it contributes. It is a better question than how long the whiskey ages, and the answer is usually more interesting.

Tagged

bourbon yeastfermentationproprietary yeast straincongenerssour mash

Common Questions

Frequently Asked

What does yeast do in bourbon?
It converts sugar into alcohol, and in doing so produces congeners — esters, acids and higher alcohols — that carry most of the fruit and floral character. Oak supplies vanilla, caramel and colour; the yeast supplies almost everything that is not wood.
What does sour mash actually mean?
That spent mash from a previous distillation, called backset, was added to the new cook to lower its pH. It suppresses competing bacteria and keeps each batch starting the same way. It is a consistency control, not a flavour, and nearly all Kentucky bourbon uses it.
Why do distilleries keep their yeast secret?
Because it is the one thing a competitor cannot copy. A mash bill can be replicated and barrels can be bought, but a strain propagated continuously for decades cannot be, which makes it the most defensible part of a house style.
Can yeast really change how bourbon tastes?
Substantially. Four Roses runs five yeast strains across two mash bills to produce ten distinct recipes from one distillery, with the same water, warehouses and staff. The differences between them are largely fermentation.
Does fermentation time affect bourbon flavour?
Yes. Both the length of the ferment and the temperature it runs at change which congeners the yeast produces, so two batches of identical grain can finish with noticeably different fruit and spice character.

Featured in this story

Bottles in this Story

Keep Reading

All Stories →