Is Elmer T. Lee the same as Blanton's?
No, but they are close relatives. Both are Buffalo Trace single barrels built on the same grain recipe, listed here as 81% corn, 8% rye and 11% malted barley, and Elmer T. Lee created Blanton's, the first single barrel bourbon, before retiring in 1985. His namesake bottling is 90 proof from Warehouse C at $80, where Blanton's Original is 93 proof at $150.
How old is Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel?
There is no age statement on the label, so no exact figure is published. The barrels behind it sit in the region of nine years, and because each bottle is filled from one barrel the age moves a little from bottle to bottle. At 90 proof, 45% ABV, that maturity shows as roundness rather than oak.
What does Elmer T. Lee taste like?
Honeyed and soft. The nose is honey, toasted vanilla, caramel and baked pear over warm oak, and the palate is silky and balanced, with caramel apple, honeycomb and light cinnamon before a medium finish of sweet oak and honey. With only 8% rye in the recipe and a 90-proof bottling, there is very little bite to it.
Why is Elmer T. Lee so hard to find?
It is bottled one barrel at a time rather than batched, so the quantity behind each selection is small, and it has been an enthusiasts' bottle for decades. We receive it as an allocation rather than ordering it freely, and there is no case format, so bottles are sold individually. When it is listed here, that is the allocation we hold.
How should I drink Elmer T. Lee?
Neat, or over a single ice cube. Elmer T. Lee was known for saying that any way you enjoy it is the right way, and at 90 proof the whiskey takes a cube without falling apart. A Glencairn shows the honey and baked pear most clearly, though it also makes a soft, sweet old-fashioned if you would rather mix than sip.
Does every bottle of Elmer T. Lee taste the same?
No, because it is a true single barrel: each bottle is filled from one cask, and the balance of honey, caramel and spice shifts between barrels. The house character holds because barrels are hand-selected from Warehouse C against a consistent profile, so the differences are a matter of degree rather than direction. The strength is fixed at 90 proof for every bottle.